Steelers Search for Answers at Safety: 4 Free-Agent Options After Minkah Fitzpatrick Trade
In a move that has stunned fans and analysts alike, the Pittsburgh Steelers have traded away star safety Minkah Fitzpatrick, signaling a major shift in the team’s defensive identity. Fitzpatrick, widely regarded as one of the top safeties in the NFL, had become a leader and key playmaker in the Steelers’ secondary. His departure leaves a significant gap that must be addressed quickly as the team prepares for the 2025 season.
With training camp just around the corner, the Steelers front office must now turn its focus to the free-agent market in search of a veteran safety who can provide immediate impact. There are several seasoned players available who could help fill the void left by Fitzpatrick. Here are four free-agent safeties the Steelers should strongly consider.
1. Justin Simmons
Former Denver Broncos standout Justin Simmons remains one of the most talented safeties on the market. A two-time Pro Bowler and four-time second-team All-Pro selection, Simmons brings elite ball skills, high football IQ, and consistency. With 30 interceptions and over 500 tackles in his career, he’s proven to be a reliable force in both pass coverage and run support.
At 31 years old, Simmons still has enough left in the tank to contribute at a high level. His experience and leadership would make him an excellent addition to Pittsburgh’s defense, which now lacks a true anchor in the secondary.
2. Kareem Jackson
Though nearing the end of his career, veteran Kareem Jackson offers experience and toughness that could benefit the Steelers in the short term. With 14 years in the league, Jackson has seen it all and played multiple roles in the secondary, including time at both safety and cornerback.
While he may no longer be a full-time starter, Jackson’s versatility and football savvy would make him a valuable depth piece and mentor. His aggressive style fits well with the Steelers’ defensive philosophy, and he could help ease the transition for younger players.
3. John Johnson III
John Johnson III is a younger option who brings both experience and versatility to the table. At 29, he still has productive years ahead of him. Johnson has played in both free and strong safety roles during his time with the Rams and Browns and is known for his communication skills and smart play.
He would be a logical addition to the Steelers’ defense, capable of stepping into a starting role while also bringing leadership and adaptability. Johnson’s knowledge of complex schemes would make him a seamless fit in Pittsburgh’s defense.
4. Tony Jefferson
Tony Jefferson may not be the player he once was due to recent injuries, but his toughness and leadership remain valuable assets. Having played for teams like the Ravens and 49ers, Jefferson is no stranger to high-stakes football and physical defensive systems.
At 33, Jefferson would likely serve as a depth option or veteran mentor, but if healthy, he could still contribute in sub-packages and on special teams. His experience in the AFC North also makes him a familiar face in one of football’s toughest divisions.
The loss of Minkah Fitzpatrick is a significant blow to the Steelers, both on the field and in the locker room. However, Pittsburgh has a history of adjusting quickly and finding veteran talent to fill key roles. Whether they pursue a proven starter like Simmons or a steady veteran like Jackson or Jefferson, the Steelers need to act fast to address the void in their secondary.
With a strong core still in place on defense, the right addition at safety could help Pittsburgh remain competitive in the AFC and continue their tradition of defensive excellence.
About the Author
